Consistency tests for comparing astrophysical models and observations

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society Oxford University Press (OUP) 524:1 (2023) 1061-1074

Authors:

Fiorenzo Stoppa, Eric Cator, Gijs Nelemans

Abstract:

ABSTRACT In astronomy, there is an opportunity to enhance the practice of validating models through statistical techniques, specifically to account for measurement error uncertainties. While models are commonly used to describe observations, there are instances where there is a lack of agreement between the two. This can occur when models are derived from incomplete theories, when a better-fitting model is not available or when measurement uncertainties are not correctly considered. However, with the application of specific tests that assess the consistency between observations and astrophysical models in a model-independent way, it is possible to address this issue. The consistency tests (ConTESTs) developed in this paper use a combination of non-parametric methods and distance measures to obtain a test statistic that evaluates the closeness of the astrophysical model to the observations. To draw conclusions on the consistency hypothesis, a simulation-based methodology is performed. In particular, we built two tests for density models and two for regression models to be used depending on the case at hand and the power of the test needed. We used ConTEST to examine synthetic examples in order to determine the effectiveness of the tests and provide guidance on using them while building a model. We also applied ConTEST to various astronomy cases, identifying which models were consistent and, if not, identifying the probable causes of rejection.

Possible contribution of X-ray binary jets to the Galactic cosmic ray and neutrino flux

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society Oxford University Press (OUP) 524:1 (2023) 1326-1342

Authors:

D Kantzas, S Markoff, AJ Cooper, D Gaggero, M Petropoulou, P De La Torre Luque

Ultra diffuse galaxies in the Hydra I cluster from the LEWISProject: Phase-Space distribution and globular cluster richness

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters Oxford University Press (OUP) 525:1 (2023) l93-l97

Authors:

Duncan A Forbes, Jonah Gannon, Enrichetta Iodice, Michael Hilker, Goran Doll, Chiara Buttitta, Antonio La Marca, Magda Arnaboldi, Michele Cantiello, G D’Ago, Jesus Falcon Barroso, Laura Greggio, Marco Gullieuszik, Johanna Hartke, Steffen Mieske, Marco Mirabile, Roberto Rampazzo, Marina Rejkuba, Marilena Spavone, Chiara Spiniello, Giulio Capasso

Calculations of multipole transitions in Sn II for kilonova analysis

The European Physical Journal D Springer 77:7 (2023) 126

Authors:

AI Bondarev, JH Gillanders, C Cheung, MS Safronova, S Fritzsche

Abstract:

We use the method that combines linearized coupled-cluster and configuration interaction approaches for calculating energy levels and multipole transition probabilities in singly ionized tin ions. We show that our calculated energies agree very well with the experimental data. We present probabilities of magnetic dipole and electric quadrupole transitions and use them for the analysis of the AT2017gfo kilonova emission spectra. This study demonstrates the importance and utility of accurate atomic data for forbidden transitions in the examination of future kilonova events. Graphical abstrac

Precise measurements of self-absorbed rising reverse shock emission from gamma-ray burst 221009A

Nature Astronomy Nature Research 7:8 (2023) 986-995

Authors:

Joe S Bright, Lauren Rhodes, Wael Farah, Rob Fender, Alexander J van der Horst, James K Leung, David RA Williams, Gemma E Anderson, Pikky Atri, David R DeBoer, Stefano Giarratana, David A Green, Ian Heywood, Emil Lenc, Tara Murphy, Alexander W Pollak, Pranav H Premnath, Paul F Scott, Sofia Z Sheikh, Andrew Siemion, David J Titterington

Abstract:

Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs) are brief flashes of gamma-rays that last from a fraction of second up to a few hundreds of seconds, during which a significant amount of isotropic equivalent energy is released (ranging from 10^48 to 10^54 erg). These explosive transients are associated with the catastrophic explosion of an isolated massive star (long-duration GRBs), or with the merger of compact objects (short-duration GRBs). Both scenarios lead to the formation of a highly magnetised neutron star or a spinning, stellar-mass black hole, which are thought to accrete material and launch two relativistic jets, causing the observed gamma-ray emission via magnetic processes or internal shocks. These jets interact with the surrounding material, producing the afterglow emission that extends from gamma-rays to radio waves. To understand GRB formation and evolution, a standard model involving an ultra-relativistic outflow is commonly employed. However, even sophisticated models face degeneracy in the multi-dimensional parameter space. To alleviate or possibly break the degeneracy, broad-band observations across the electromagnetic spectrum are crucial. In particular, the Very Long Baseline Interferometry technique (VLBI) has proven to be a unique asset, providing direct evidence of apparent superluminal expansion (for on-axis GRBs), centroid displacement of the outflow (for slightly off-axis GRBs) and the first confirmation that merger events can launch successful jets. In this Thesis, we employed radio and VLBI observations to characterise and constrain the outflow, the circum-burst medium, and the properties of the progenitors of GRBs. This included studies on individual events (GRB201015A and GRB221009A), which are important to test the predictions of current models, GRB host galaxies (GRB200716C), which are fundamental to constrain the nature of the progenitor through the characterisation of the surrounding environment, and the statistical properties of GRB afterglows, in order to verify the existence of potential GRB sub-populations