Colloquium: The Cosmic Dipole Anomaly

Reviews of Modern Physics American Physical Society

Authors:

Sebastian Von Hausegger, Roya mohayaee, nathan secrest, rameez, Subir Sarkar

Abstract:

The Cosmological Principle, which states that the Universe is homogeneous and isotropic (when averaged on large scales), is the foundational assumption of Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) cosmologies such as the current standard Lambda-Cold-Dark-Matter (ΛCDM) model. This simplification yields an exact solution to the Einstein field equations that relates space and time through a single time-dependent scale factor, which defines cosmological observables such as the Hubble parameter and the cosmological redshift. The validity of the Cosmological Principle, which underpins modern cosmology, can now be rigorously tested with the advent of large, nearly all-sky catalogs of radio galaxies and quasars. Surprisingly, the dipole anisotropy in the large-scale distribution of matter is found to be inconsistent with the expectation from kinematic aberration and Doppler boosting effects in a perturbed FLRW universe, which is the standard interpretation of the observed dipole in the cosmic microwave background (CMB). Although the matter dipole agrees in direction with that of the CMB dipole, it is anomalously larger, demonstrating that either the rest frames in which matter and radiation appear isotropic are not the same, or that there is an unexpected intrinsic anisotropy in at least one of them. This discrepancy now exceeds 5σ in significance. We review these recent findings, as well as the potential biases, systematic issues, and alternate interpretations that have been suggested to help alleviate the tension. We conclude that the cosmic dipole anomaly poses a serious challenge to FLRW cosmology, and the standard ΛCDM model in particular, as an adequate description of our Universe.

Finding radio transients

Abstract:

Modern radio telescopes are data-intensive machines, producing many TB of data every night. Amongst this deluge of data are transient and variable phenomena, whose study can shed new light on processes as varied as stellar dynamos and the accretion discs in supermassive black holes. In this work I demonstrate the applicability of different methods to the discovery of these astrophysical transients and variables coming from telescopes such as MeerKAT.

I first consider a standard approach to discovering transients by characterising their variability. By making use of even modest sampling with the high sensitivity and wide field of view of MeerKAT, I demonstrate how we are now able to uncover new transients almost by accident - if we exclude the vast amount of time spent planning, building and operating excellent telescopes, efficient pipelines and well- crafted observing proposals. In this work I found a stellar flare from a nearby M dwarf, which was then followed up and complemented by optical and X-ray photometry and spectroscopy, providing new insights on the system.

Next I built a citizen science platform in order to perform such transient searches at scale, making use of a wide range of data available in the MeerKAT archive. I detail the process of review and beta-testing that resulted in the final design of the Bursts from Space: MeerKAT project. Over 1000 volunteers took part, demonstrating a healthy appetite for further Zooniverse data releases. Volunteers discovered or recovered a wide range of phenomena, from flare stars and pulsars to scintillating AGN and transient OH maser emission. I was also able to use the known transients in our fields to understand some reasons why interesting sources may be missed and will fold this learning through to future iterations of the project. This is the first demonstration of volunteers finding radio transients in images.

Finally, I show how anomaly detection, an unsupervised machine learning approach, is a suitable tool for finding these variable phenomena at scale, as is required for modern astronomical surveys. I use three feature sets as applied to two anomaly detection techniques in the Astronomaly package and analyse anomaly detection performance by comparison with citizen science labels. By using transients found by citizen scientists as a ground truth I demonstrate that anomaly detection techniques can recall over half of the radio transients within 10% of the sample dataset. I find that the choice of feature set is crucial, especially when considering available resources for human inspection and follow-up. I find that active learning on ∼2% of the data improves recall by up to 10%, depending on the feature-model pair. The best performing feature-model pairs result in a factor of 5 times fewer sources requiring vetting by humans. This is the first effort to apply anomaly detection techniques to finding radio transients and shows great promise for application to other datasets, a real-time transient detection system and upcoming large surveys.

Gain Stabilization for Radio Intensity Mapping using a Continuous-Wave Reference Signal

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society Oxford University Press (OUP)

Authors:

Alexander W Pollak, Christian M Holler, Michael E Jones, Angela C Taylor

Abstract:

Stabilizing the gain of a radio astronomy receiver is of great importance for sensitive radio intensity mapping. In this paper we discuss a stabilization method using a continuous-wave reference signal injected into the signal chain and tracked in a single channel of the spectrometer to correct for the gain variations of the receiver. This method depends on the fact that gain fluctuations of the receiver are strongly correlated across the frequency band, which we can show is the case for our experimental setup. This method is especially suited for receivers with a digital back-end with high spectral resolution and moderate dynamic range. The sensitivity of the receiver is unaltered except for one lost frequency channel. We present experimental results using a new 4-8.5 GHz receiver with a digital back-end that shows substantial reduction of the 1/ f noise and the 1/ f knee frequency.

Group connectivity in COSMOS: a tracer of mass assembly history

Authors:

E Darragh-Ford, C Laigle, G Gozaliasl, C Pichon, JULIEN Devriendt, A Slyz, S Arnouts, Y Dubois, A Finoguenov, R Griffiths, K Kraljic, H Pan, S Peirani, F Sarron

Abstract:

Cosmic filaments are the channel through which galaxy groups assemble their mass. Cosmic connectivity, namely the number of filaments connected to a given group, is therefore expected to be an important ingredient in shaping group properties. The local connectivity is measured in COSMOS around X-Ray detected groups between redshift 0.5 and 1.2. To this end, large-scale filaments are extracted using the accurate photometric redshifts of the COSMOS2015 catalogue in two-dimensional slices of thickness 120 comoving Mpc centred on the group's redshift. The link between connectivity, group mass and the properties of the brightest group galaxy (BGG) is investigated. The same measurement is carried out on mocks extracted from the lightcone of the hydrodynamical simulation Horizon-AGN in order to control systematics. More massive groups are on average more connected. At fixed group mass in low-mass groups, BGG mass is slightly enhanced at high connectivity, while in high mass groups BGG mass is lower at higher connectivity. Groups with a star-forming BGG have on average a lower connectivity at given mass. From the analysis of the Horizon-AGN simulation, we postulate that different connectivities trace different paths of group mass assembly: at high group mass, groups with higher connectivity are more likely to have grown through a recent major merger, which might be in turn the reason for the quenching of the BGG. Future large-field photometric surveys, such as Euclid and LSST, will be able to confirm and extend these results by probing a wider mass range and a larger variety of environment.

Improving Photometric Redshift Estimation using GPz: size information, post processing and improved photometry

Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society Blackwell Publishing Inc.

Authors:

Z Gomes, MJ Jarvis, IA Almosallam, SJ Roberts

Abstract:

The next generation of large scale imaging surveys (such as those conducted with the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope and Euclid) will require accurate photometric redshifts in order to optimally extract cosmological information. Gaussian Processes for photometric redshift estimation (GPz) is a promising new method that has been proven to provide efficient, accurate photometric redshift estimations with reliable variance predictions. In this paper, we investigate a number of methods for improving the photometric redshift estimations obtained using GPz (but which are also applicable to others). We use spectroscopy from the Galaxy and Mass Assembly Data Release 2 with a limiting magnitude of r<19.4 along with corresponding Sloan Digital Sky Survey visible (ugriz) photometry and the UKIRT Infrared Deep Sky Survey Large Area Survey near-IR (YJHK) photometry. We evaluate the effects of adding near-IR magnitudes and angular size as features for the training, validation and testing of GPz and find that these improve the accuracy of the results by ~15-20 per cent. In addition, we explore a post-processing method of shifting the probability distributions of the estimated redshifts based on their Quantile-Quantile plots and find that it improves the bias by ~40 per cent. Finally, we investigate the effects of using more precise photometry obtained from the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program Data Release 1 and find that it produces significant improvements in accuracy, similar to the effect of including additional features.