The signal-to-noise paradox in climate forecasts: revisiting our understanding and identifying future priorities

Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society American Meteorological Society 105 (2024) E651-E659

Authors:

Antje Weisheimer, Laura Baker, Jochen Bröcker, Chaim Garfinkel, Steven Hardiman, Dan Hodson, Tim Palmer, J Robson, Adam Scaife, James Screen, T Shepherd, D Smith, R Sutton

The role of in situ ocean data assimilation in ECMWF subseasonal forecasts of sea‐surface temperature and mixed‐layer depth over the tropical Pacific ocean.

Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society 149:757 (2023) 3513-3524

Authors:

Wei, H.H., Subramanian, A.C., Karnauskas, K.B., Du, D., Balmaseda, M.A., Sarojini, B.B., Vitart, F., DeMott, C.A. and Mazloff, M.R., 2023.

Abstract:

The tropical Pacific plays an important role in modulating the global climate through its prevailing sea-surface temperature spatial structure and dominant climate modes like El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO), the Madden–Julian Oscillation (MJO), and their teleconnections. These modes of variability, including their oceanic anomalies, are considered to provide sources of prediction skill on subseasonal timescales in the Tropics. Therefore, this study aims to examine how assimilating in situ ocean observations influences the initial ocean sea-surface temperature (SST) and mixed-layer depth (MLD) and their subseasonal forecasts. We analyze two subseasonal forecast systems generated with the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) Integrated Forecast System (IFS), where the ocean states were initialized using two Observing-System Experiment (OSE) reanalyses. We find that the SST differences between forecasts with and without ocean data assimilation grow with time, resulting in a reduced cold-tongue bias when assimilating ocean observations. Two mechanisms related to air–sea coupling are considered to contribute to this growth of SST differences. One is a positive feedback between the zonal SST gradient, pressure gradient, and surface wind. The other is the difference in Ekman suction and mixing at the Equator due to surface wind-speed differences. While the initial mixed-layer depth (MLD) can be improved through ocean data assimilation, this improvement is not maintained in the forecasts. Instead, the MLD in both experiments shoals rapidly at the beginning of the forecast. These results emphasize how initialization and model biases influence air–sea interaction and the accuracy of subseasonal forecasts in the tropical Pacific.

The role of in situ ocean data assimilation in ECMWF subseasonal forecasts of sea‐surface temperature and mixed‐layer depth over the tropical Pacific ocean.

Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society 149:757 (2023) 3513-3524

Authors:

Wei, H.H., Subramanian, A.C., Karnauskas, K.B., Du, D., Balmaseda, M.A., Sarojini, B.B., Vitart, F., DeMott, C.A. and Mazloff, M.R., 2023.

Abstract:

The tropical Pacific plays an important role in modulating the global climate through its prevailing sea-surface temperature spatial structure and dominant climate modes like El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO), the Madden–Julian Oscillation (MJO), and their teleconnections. These modes of variability, including their oceanic anomalies, are considered to provide sources of prediction skill on subseasonal timescales in the Tropics. Therefore, this study aims to examine how assimilating in situ ocean observations influences the initial ocean sea-surface temperature (SST) and mixed-layer depth (MLD) and their subseasonal forecasts. We analyze two subseasonal forecast systems generated with the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) Integrated Forecast System (IFS), where the ocean states were initialized using two Observing-System Experiment (OSE) reanalyses. We find that the SST differences between forecasts with and without ocean data assimilation grow with time, resulting in a reduced cold-tongue bias when assimilating ocean observations. Two mechanisms related to air–sea coupling are considered to contribute to this growth of SST differences. One is a positive feedback between the zonal SST gradient, pressure gradient, and surface wind. The other is the difference in Ekman suction and mixing at the Equator due to surface wind-speed differences. While the initial mixed-layer depth (MLD) can be improved through ocean data assimilation, this improvement is not maintained in the forecasts. Instead, the MLD in both experiments shoals rapidly at the beginning of the forecast. These results emphasize how initialization and model biases influence air–sea interaction and the accuracy of subseasonal forecasts in the tropical Pacific.

The link between North Atlantic tropical cyclones and ENSO in seasonal forecasts

Atmospheric Science Letters Wiley 25:1 (2023) e1190

Authors:

Robert Doane-Solomon, Daniel J Befort, Joanne Camp, Kevin Hodges, Antje Weisheimer

Abstract:

This study assesses the ability of six European seasonal forecast models to simulate the observed teleconnection between ENSO and tropical cyclones (TCs) over the North Atlantic. While the models generally capture the basin-wide observed link, its magnitude is overestimated in all forecast models compared to reanalysis. Furthermore, the ENSO-TC relationship in the Caribbean is poorly simulated. It is shown that incorrect forecasting of wind shear appears to affect the representation of the teleconnection in some models, however it is not a completely sufficient explanation for the overestimation of the link.

The role of in situ ocean data assimilation in ECMWF subseasonal forecasts of sea‐surface temperature and mixed‐layer depth over the tropical Pacific ocean.

Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society 149:757 (2023) 3513-3524

Authors:

Wei, H.H., Subramanian, A.C., Karnauskas, K.B., Du, D., Balmaseda, M.A., Sarojini, B.B., Vitart, F., DeMott, C.A. and Mazloff, M.R., 2023.

Abstract:

The tropical Pacific plays an important role in modulating the global climate through its prevailing sea-surface temperature spatial structure and dominant climate modes like El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO), the Madden–Julian Oscillation (MJO), and their teleconnections. These modes of variability, including their oceanic anomalies, are considered to provide sources of prediction skill on subseasonal timescales in the Tropics. Therefore, this study aims to examine how assimilating in situ ocean observations influences the initial ocean sea-surface temperature (SST) and mixed-layer depth (MLD) and their subseasonal forecasts. We analyze two subseasonal forecast systems generated with the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) Integrated Forecast System (IFS), where the ocean states were initialized using two Observing-System Experiment (OSE) reanalyses. We find that the SST differences between forecasts with and without ocean data assimilation grow with time, resulting in a reduced cold-tongue bias when assimilating ocean observations. Two mechanisms related to air–sea coupling are considered to contribute to this growth of SST differences. One is a positive feedback between the zonal SST gradient, pressure gradient, and surface wind. The other is the difference in Ekman suction and mixing at the Equator due to surface wind-speed differences. While the initial mixed-layer depth (MLD) can be improved through ocean data assimilation, this improvement is not maintained in the forecasts. Instead, the MLD in both experiments shoals rapidly at the beginning of the forecast. These results emphasize how initialization and model biases influence air–sea interaction and the accuracy of subseasonal forecasts in the tropical Pacific.